There are few kitchen pleasures more immediate than a toasted sandwich. Two slices of bread, a generous stuffing of cheese, perhaps some leftover ham or a slick of chutney, and a few minutes of patience. The right machine seals it all together into something crisp, molten, and deeply satisfying. The wrong one gives you a lukewarm bread envelope with cheese welded to the plates.

We looked at what is currently available from UK retailers, focusing on build quality, customer trust in the brand, ease of cleaning, and whether the thing will last beyond its first encounter with a determined Cheddar. Here are five worth considering, from cheerful budget buy to serious upgrade.

Quick picks

  • Best overall: Breville Diagonal 2-Slice Sandwich Toaster
  • Best value: George Foreman Entertaining 10-Portion Grill
  • Best compact design: Tower Cerasure 2 Slice Sandwich Maker
  • Best upgrade: Cuisinart 2-in-1 Grill & Sandwich Maker
  • Best for families: Breville Deep Fill 2-Slice Sandwich Toaster

What matters when choosing

Plate coating and cleaning. Non-stick plates are non-negotiable. Removable, dishwasher-safe plates are a genuine luxury. Cheese will escape; the question is how easily you recover from that.

Seal and cut. Diagonal-cut models seal the edges and slice the sandwich in one press, which keeps fillings where they belong. Flat-plate grills give more flexibility but less containment.

Size and storage. A compact maker with cord wrap and upright storage earns its place in a small kitchen. A bulky unit that lives on the worktop needs to justify the space.

Our picks

1. Best overall: Breville Diagonal 2-Slice Sandwich Toaster VST077

Breville has been making toasted sandwich makers since the 1970s, and they have not forgotten how. The VST077 cuts diagonally, seals edges properly, and has deep-fill plates that accommodate a thick layer of filling without protest. The non-stick coating cleans easily with a damp cloth. It is compact, has cord storage, and locks shut for upright storage. Breville consistently scores well for customer trust in kitchen electricals, and this model reflects that reliability.

Limitation: Fixed plates only, so you cannot swap to a flat grill.

Price: Around £30. Available from John Lewis.

2. Best value: George Foreman Entertaining 10-Portion Grill 23440

If you want a flat grill that handles toasted sandwiches alongside halloumi, chicken, and vegetables, this George Foreman is exceptional value. The large plate area suits batch cooking or feeding a crowd. Removable plates go in the dishwasher. It will not cut and seal like a dedicated sandwich maker, but it earns its place through sheer versatility.

Limitation: Large footprint. Not ideal for a single toastie in a tiny kitchen.

Price: Around £35. Available from Currys.

3. Best compact design: Tower Cerasure 2 Slice Sandwich Maker T27030RG

Tower's Cerasure range uses a ceramic-stone non-stick coating, which the brand claims is longer lasting than standard non-stick. It looks smart in rose gold and black, locks for upright storage, and takes up very little space. Tower has built a solid reputation for affordable, well-designed kitchen appliances.

Limitation: Shallower fill than the Breville, so be restrained with your stuffing.

Price: Around £20. Available from Amazon.

4. Best upgrade: Cuisinart 2-in-1 Grill & Sandwich Maker GRSM4U

Cuisinart brings removable, dishwasher-safe plates and a floating hinge that adjusts to different bread thicknesses. Build quality feels a step above, with a brushed stainless steel housing. It ships with both sandwich and grill plates, so you genuinely get two machines in one.

Limitation: The price. You are paying for the engineering and the brand.

Price: Around £60. Available from John Lewis.

5. Best for families: Breville Deep Fill 2-Slice Sandwich Toaster VST041

The VST041 has deeper plates than the VST077, designed specifically for generous fillings. If your household runs to beans, cheese, and sweetcorn in a single sandwich, this is the machine that will not judge you. Cut-and-seal plates keep everything contained.

Limitation: The deeper plates take slightly longer to heat through, and it is a touch bulkier.

Price: Around £28. Available from Tesco.

How we chose

We reviewed current product listings and specifications from John Lewis, Currys, Tesco, and Amazon, cross-referenced with customer reviews on those platforms and independent assessments. Press For Wine has not conducted hands-on testing of these appliances. Brand trust scores were assessed through aggregated customer review data and long-term brand reputation in the UK small appliance market. Prices and availability were checked in June 2025.

FAQ

Do I need a sandwich maker or will a frying pan do?

A frying pan with a weight on top makes a perfectly good toasted sandwich. A dedicated maker seals the edges and saves you standing over the hob. It is a convenience, not a necessity.

Can I make toasted sandwiches with sourdough?

Yes, though thicker slices may not fit in shallower models. The Cuisinart's floating hinge handles variable bread thickness best.

What is the best cheese for a toasted sandwich?

A mature Cheddar that melts well is hard to beat. Gruyère or Comté bring nuttiness. Mozzarella gives the stretch. A blend of strong and melty is the real answer.

The short version

For most people, the Breville VST077 at around £30 does everything a toasted sandwich maker should, reliably and without fuss. If you want deeper fills, the VST041 costs slightly less and takes more stuffing. If you want versatility beyond sandwiches, the George Foreman earns its worktop space. And if your toasted sandwich habit is serious enough to warrant investment, the Cuisinart is a genuinely lovely piece of kit. Now go and buy some decent cheese.